The picture at the top of this blog is a photograph of a mechanical calculator: a Walther, probably a model RMKZ, and indeed manufactured by the still-existing firearms company. I’ve been interested in mechanical calculators (and “coffee grinder arithmetic”) ever since reading Husserl’s Philosophy of Arithmetic, where he speaks repeatedly of the “mechanical operations” of elementary arithmetic, the numerical symbols as foundation for a “completely mechanical process” of calculation, “purely mechanical counting”, etc. He even points out that we count “like a machine” (“maschinenmässig”), when blindly manipulating signs due to habit. The first time I read this I wondered what level of mechanical calculation had been reached in the 1880’s when Husserl wrote this. I obtained a more than satisfactory answer to this question when visiting the excellent Arithmeum in Bonn a few years later. From caveman arithmetic with notches on a stick to the last mechanical calculators of the 1970s they have nearly everything there (including an Enigma). After the Pascaline, the development of mechanical calculation took flight in the 19th century, starting with Babbage’s difference engine in 1822. This lead to a veritable “computing revolution” in the 1880s and 1890s, right around the time Husserl was writing his book, when all kinds of new models of mechanical calculators were being developed and mass-produced.
Inspired by the picture on my blog, this year for my birthday my mother gave me an Original Odhner model 239, probably produced in the late 1950s or early ‘60s, complete with copies of the original manual and instructions for disassembling and cleaning it. During the summer break I plan to take it apart, peek into Leibniz’ mill, and put it back together.
I admired your skill. Handy man.
I am absolutely an A technical person (76).
I worked in the past in office with Odhner.
Now I am proud owner of Odhner 239
serialnummer 239-883237 (exact building
year unknow to me).
I shall never have the courage to dismantle
so a stay with the position as machine has.
I just have question how to oily machine
without any dusmantling.
Machine works but I feel it needs some
oil.
Thanks for your kind attention.
Appreciate all your interests in pinwheel
calculators.
Best regards,
Henri
Thank you for your comment! I found a great resource for mechanical calculators here: http://home.vicnet.net.au/~wolff/calculators/Odhner/Odhner.htm
For oiling without disassembling, you would just need to remove the outer covers so you can reach the mechanism.
All the best,
Carlo
Thanks Carlo for extremely prompt reaction/answer.
Even removing cover will make me “nervous” so I
shall try to let oil in via openings in front.
By the way : I have a REMA 1 (1915) compleet with
wooden cover, all in an excellent condition.
Further as well a Thales Patent, a pre-war one.
Best regards,
Henri
PLEASE H E L P
My Odhner 239 operated correctly up till ……….
at once it was completely blocked. All the pinns
are on position 77777777 no movement in all
facets. If you look at the manual in German language
it says that löschung is to be done by
holding
thum and to move handle a quarter clockwise.
Not any movement, whilst handle stays fixed
in position quarter way.
The machine is absolutely in good order so
for me (76) and not being a handy man it is a miracle.
I feel unhappy on moment. I cannot suppose
something is broken or whatever.
Look forward for your kind help.
Best regards Henri
Manual page 7 -Die löschung des Rinstellwerkes (10) –
So I have no succes with action 10 plus 2 of above
manual
I’m sorry to hear that your machine is not working. John Wolff’s website on mechanical calculators has some very detailed instructions on how to clean and repair an Odhner: http://home.vicnet.net.au/~wolff/calculators/Tech/Overhaul/Overhaul.htm
I hope that you can find some good advice over there.
Dear Carlo,
Apologize for late reaction. With your advice and via via I came in contact
with Cris Van de Velde in Belgium. He had a very extensive collection of
old calculators. He is, moreover , an excellent expert in this field. I
visited Cris twice and in a helpful way he solved the problem witrh my
Odhner 239, so the machine works correctly again.
I suppose you know Cris. If not look at his extensive site. It is amazing.
Thanks Carlo for you cooperation.
Succes with the hobby!
Kind regards
Henri